49 Delicious Homemade Coffee Creamer Recipes to Get Your Day Started (2024)

What beverage do you reach for first thing in the morning?

Are you someone that loves to sip on herbal tea first thing, or do you reach for hot chocolate? What about water?

Or are you like me and love a big cup of coffee as soon as your feet hit the floor?

Well, if you are a coffee drinker, do you like it black or with some added flavor? I’ll be honest, my husband likes his coffee strong and black, but me, not so much. Coffee is my treat first thing in the morning, and I like for it to be flavorful and something that I enjoy so I can start my day on the right foot.

So that is why I’m bringing you a variety of homemade coffee creamer recipes. It should help you save money since you can make them yourself.

Also, it brings me comfort making things from scratch because not only am I practicing self-sufficiency, but I also know what is in my food.

Homemade Coffee Creamer Recipes:

1. Pumpkin Coffee Creamer

Truthfully, I am not a big fan of pumpkin desserts. I know, I’m a weirdo. But everyone else in my house loves them!

So when I saw this recipe I had to share because my oldest son would probably never forgive me if I didn’t, since pumpkin coffee creamer is his absolute favorite. If you love pumpkin as much as he does, then you’ll want to give this recipe a go.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

2. Almond Joy Coffee Creamer

Do you love the Almond Joy candy bars? If so, then this coffee creamer could be right up your alley. It has only five ingredients, which makes it that much more appealing.

So if you are looking for a simple coffee creamer recipe that will feel like a sweet treat to start your day, then you will most definitely want to check this one out.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

3. Crème Brule Coffee Creamer

Does the name not just sound super delicious? Anything Crème Brule, I’m usually a huge fan of. Naturally, this coffee creamer caught my attention.

Plus, it has only 4 super simple ingredients. Why wouldn’t you love this creamer? Super simple to make and very delicious too.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

4. Homemade Marshmallow Coffee Creamer

Easter is coming up and when I saw this recipe for coffee creamer and it has the little bunny Peeps sticking out of the cup I knew I must share.

So if you’d like something a little festive, then give this coffee creamer a try. It adds a lot of marshmallowy goodness to your morning brew.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

5. The Trim Healthy Mama Autumn Spice Coffee Creamer

I have a confession. My husband and I have been doing the low carb, low sugar diet for quite some time now. My husband’s cardiologist put him on it and my doctor told me it could help me too.

But you have to get creative because practically everything we eat has carbs and sugar in it. Look no further than this coffee creamer recipe if you are on that diet and craving something festive.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

6. Sisters Saving Cents Almond Joy Creamer

If you like the idea of saving money making your own condiments are a great way to accomplish that. Which is exactly why these sisters created their own Almond Joy coffee creamer recipe.

So if you’d like to have a tasty cup of coffee in the mornings while also saving money, then you should check out this recipe.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

7. White Chocolate Raspberry Coffee Creamer

Are you someone that likes to try rich flavors in their favorite coffee? Do you consider yourself adventurous with flavors?

Well, if so, then you’ll want to try this decadent coffee creamer. It is meant to infuse both the flavors of raspberries and white chocolate. Yum!

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

8. Vanilla Cinnamon Coffee Creamer

Vanilla and cinnamon are both very common flavors that many people love. It is traditional and comforting.

So if you’d like to have those warm flavors infused into your morning coffee, then you’ll want to give this coffee creamer recipe a go.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

9. Thin Mint Creamer

I have a super weakness for Girl Scout cookies. All of those delicious cookies are addictive! Not surprisingly, I love thin mints the best. As I think a lot of people do.

Naturally, my eyes lit up when I saw this recipe for homemade thin mint coffee creamer. What a great combo…freshly brewed coffee and thin mints. Only now, I get to have them both in one cup.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

10. Peppermint Creamer

If you love peppermint, then you’ll want to give this recipe a try. It is a really simple recipe that would be great for use around the holidays.

Plus, it is non-dairy powdered cream (for those that prefer that.) You just crush up candy canes and combine with the non-dairy powder. It is that easy.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

11. Caramel Marshmallow Coffee Creamer

Do you like frothiness in your coffee? What about the subtle taste of caramel? If so, then you’ll want to give this recipe a quick try.

Plus, it has only 6 basic ingredients. You cook it on the stove for a very minimal amount of time to combine all of the delicious flavors. Then store in the fridge for up to 4 weeks. Sounds easy enough.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

12. Healthy Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer

If you’ve ever purchased store-bought coffee creamer, then you’ve probably noticed how many calories and other unhealthy additives are placed inside that creamer. It can really pack a punch to your health and waistline.

Which is why I find this recipe for pumpkin spice coffee creamer such a great addition. It uses lower fat options in the creamer and adds lots of spices for optimal health.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

13. Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer

Apparently, I’ve taken us to ‘Pumpkin Spice Land.’ As you can tell, many people love to add pumpkin spice to their coffee.

Which is why the internet is flooded for homemade recipes for it. So if you are one of those people, take a look at this recipe and see which one you prefer.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

14. Vanilla Bean Coffee Creamer

Now we are heading up my alley. I am a simple girl that loves simple flavors when it comes to my morning cup of coffee.

So no fancy spices for me. Instead, give me simple vanilla flavors. Since this one is made with vanilla bean I bet the vanilla flavor is very prominent.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

15. Easy Vegan Coffee Creamer

Do you follow a vegan diet? If so, my hat goes off to you. I know that there are many health benefits to that type of diet, but it is hard to find recipes that are always suitable.

Well, you can now have a great coffee creamer that you can enjoy with this recipe. It is made from nut milk and vanilla extract so it certainly sounds simple enough to make.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

16. Whole 30 Paleo Coffee Creamer

So you are trying to eat a more natural diet. I understand because I’m always trying to get away from anything processed to optimize my health.

But it can be hard to find recipes that goes along with this lifestyle that doesn’t taste bland. Well, this recipe will hopefully change your mind when it comes to your cup of coffee.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

17. Paleo Vanilla Hazelnut Creamer

I love vanilla creamer in my coffee, and I also love hazelnut. They are delicious and familiar flavors, which I prefer.

So when I saw this recipe that allowed me to have my two familiar flavors in a paleo way, I was super excited and knew I must share with all of you all.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

18. Mint Chocolate Coffee Creamer

I thought of my sister when I saw this recipe. Since we were little girls, she always loved anything and everything that was mint chocolate. Even chap stick…she’d eat it off of her lips!

So I figured if there were any other people out there that loved mint chocolate even half as much as she does, then this recipe would be a hit.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

19. Irish Cream Coffee Creamer

Do you like Irish cream? I know a lot of people do. Which is why I wanted to share this recipe. It is inexpensive to make because it includes only basic ingredients.

Plus, it only takes 20 minutes to make. Think about it. That is less money (most likely) than what you’d spend at the store and a lot less time than the trip to go buy it would take.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

20. Snickers Coffee Creamer

I’ve never actually seen a Snickers coffee creamer in the store so naturally, I was intrigued by this recipe. I’m a huge fan of Snicker bars, and I love almost anything that you can purchase that tastes like Snickers.

So I’m feeling rather confident that I’d love this homemade creamer as well. Could you imagine, your morning cup of coffee and a Snicker bar all in one cup?

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

21. Amaretto Coffee Creamer

This coffee creamer is unique. It can be mixed in with coffee, hot chocolate, or even your morning tea. It also is really easy to create.

Basically, you mix a few dry ingredients together, mix well, and then store in an airtight container. Then you just toss a couple of teaspoons full of it into your hot drink whenever you are ready.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

22. 10 Paleo Coffee Creamers

This site is amazing. They have created ten different coffee creamers for those that follow a Paleo diet. If that is you, then you’ll want to check it out.

Plus, the recipes sound amazing. They have caramel macchiato and cinnabun (just to name a few.) If that sounds like something you’d enjoy, then you’ll definitely want to browse through these recipes.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

23. Pumpkin Pie Coffee Creamer

This recipe takes it one step further than a lot of the pumpkin spice recipes. This will actually turn your coffee orange (or so the pictures depict.)

But it does actually contain pumpkin puree along with the pumpkin spices. So if you want to go for the complete pumpkin package, then you’ll want to give this recipe a glance.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

24. Nikki’s Coconut Creamer

If you are looking for a non-dairy creamer then you need to not look past this one. It is super simple and sugar-free too.

Basically, you just mix some vanilla extract, coconut milk, and stevia together. Next thing you know, you have a delicious non-dairy and sugar-free creamer for your morning cup of Joe.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

25. Homemade Sweet Vanilla Coffee Creamer

This recipe for homemade vanilla coffee creamer claims to be easy and by the looks of it, it is. You’ll just take a few basic ingredients and place them in a bottle with a lid.

Then you’ll mix them all really well and place them in the fridge for storage. Finally, just be sure you mix them well before each use. That is all there is to it when it comes to this coffee creamer.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

26. Homemade Chocolate Coffee Creamer

Are you in love with chocolate? I totally get it because my mother is the same way. When I was a little girl, I’d wake up to my mother standing in the kitchen in front of the fridge in the middle of the night pouring chocolate syrup into her mouth. (Sorry, Mom!)

So if you love chocolate even half as much, then you’ll want to give this recipe a try. You’ll mix a few ingredients to make something similar to hot chocolate. Then refrigerate until you are ready to use.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

27. Paleo Vanilla Coconut Coffee Creamer

This paleo recipe sounds really good. It includes coconut milk, coconut sugar, vanilla bean, and some salt. All are pretty basic ingredients that you should be able to find at your local store or online.

Then you just heat them together in the order listed on the recipe. Finally, you’ll store until you are ready to use.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

28. Homemade Chocolate Raspberry Coffee Creamer

Do you like the flavor combination of raspberry and chocolate? If so, then you’ll want to give this recipe a try.

So you’ll combine a few basic ingredients like chocolate and raspberry preserves to make a beautiful concoction that will flavor your coffee like no other.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

29. Carb Free Coffee Creamer

I understand the struggle of finding low carb options for many things that we use in our day to day lives.

Well, this coffee creamer recipe will settle it for this daily need. You mix flavoring and heavy whipping cream to get a delectable treat to flavor your coffee.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

30. Coconut Mocha Creamer

When I was a little girl I went through a phase where I loved coconut but didn’t like chocolate. Then I loved chocolate and didn’t like coconut.

However, now that my tastes have matured (that’s a joke) I’ve discovered I’m an equal opportunity sweet snacker so I love both. Which is why I think this coffee creamer would make such a great addition to a morning cup or coffee.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

31. Coconut Milk Coffee Creamer

This seems like a really healthy option for a coffee creamer. It has only dates, coconut milk, and vanilla in it.

So if you are someone trying to stick to a healthy and all natural lifestyle, then you might find this coffee creamer to be a good fit.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

32. Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer

Do you love to buy those pumpkin spice lattes but don’t love the price? What about those delicious flavored coffees that you can only find in the fall?

Well, thanks to this coffee creamer recipe you can create these delicious beverages at home, any time you want, and without the cost.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

33. Nutella Coffee Creamer

Do you love Nutella? You know, the hazelnut spread that you can put on your toast for a delicious breakfast?

Well, if you do, then you’ll love this coffee creamer. It is basically milk, cream, and Nutella. But it should definitely make your morning coffee a treat.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

34. Homemade Powdered Coffee Creamer

I’m not a huge fan of powdered coffee creamers, but if you are, then you’ll want to check out this recipe so you can know how to make your own right at home.

Also, it looks simple enough to make and should be rather sweet too as it has powdered sugar in it.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

35. Vanilla Almond and Chocolate Coffee Creamer

This website shares two great recipes. The first is for vanilla almond coffee creamer. The second is for chocolate coffee creamer.

So if either of those sounds like a great addition to your morning, then you’ll definitely want to check them out.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

36. Caramel Machiatto

I have to admit. If I had to choose one favorite coffee creamer, caramel macchiato would probably be it. Why? Because I love caramel and its sweet taste in my coffee first thing every day.

So if you are like me and love caramel macchiato in your coffee, then you’ll want to check out this recipe to see how you can make it yourself.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

37. Super Simple Caramel Macchiato Creamer

Okay, so I added the super simple part, but when you look at the ingredients you will see how simple it is to make this delicious coffee creamer.

So if you are looking for an easy way to have your caramel macchiato fix, then you’ll want to check out this recipe.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

38. Chai Vanilla Creamer

If you enjoy chai tea, then you’ll probably enjoy this creamer. I have actually never had chai tea until a few short months ago.

And I really enjoyed it. It was a little different flavor than what I was used to, but it was definitely something I’d enjoy as a special treat.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

39. French Vanilla Coffee Creamer

I already admitted to the fact that I prefer traditional flavors in my coffee. One of those flavors I enjoy is French vanilla.

So if you are like me and love French vanilla coffee creamer, then you’ll definitely want to check out this recipe so you can make it yourself.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

40. Eggnog Coffee Creamer

I like eggnog. I know a lot of people don’t, but I actually enjoy it. The only downside is it is hard to find in the stores besides around the holidays.

So that is why I love this eggnog coffee creamer recipe. You can enjoy the flavor of eggnog in your coffee year round.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

41. Gingerbread Coffee Creamer

Do you love the taste of gingerbread cookies? Or what about making those adorable gingerbread houses?

Well, you can have that same taste in your coffee with this homemade gingerbread coffee creamer recipe.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

42. Clean Eating Coffee Creamer

Are you trying to eat cleaner? It is hard sometimes because that means we have to give up some of the things we love.

Well, that does not have to include your morning coffee with creamer. This recipe has only three ingredients, and they all should fit under the clean eating diet.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

43. Simple Homemade Coffee Creamer

If you don’t really care a lot about different flavors in your coffee, then you might really love this simple creamer recipe.

Basically, you mix milk with sweetened condensed milk and call it a day. You can add a little something sweet to your coffee without a lot of fuss.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

44. Chocolate Chip Cookie Creamer

I love chocolate chip cookies. They are probably one of my favorite cookies to make and eat fresh. Naturally, this recipe peaked my interest when I saw that I could have that same flavor in my coffee.

So I decided it needed to be shared with all of the other chocolate chip cookie lovers out there. It requires only a few basic ingredients to get the taste of fresh baked cookies in your coffee each morning.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

45. Rolos Coffee Creamer

Do you remember the delicious chocolate and caramel candies called Rolos? I have fond memories of them as a child. My grandmother would always silently slide them out of her purse and use them to keep me busy (and my mouth shut) during church.

So when I found this recipe I knew it had to be shared because after all, who doesn’t love chocolatey caramel goodness in their morning cup of coffee?

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

46. Salted Caramel Mocha Creamer

Do you love the taste of mocha? What about salted caramel? There is something about the delicious flavors of sweet and salty that makes everyone’s taste buds go wild.

So why not include such a mixture in your morning cup of coffee? It would be a great way to wake-up and start the day.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

47. Turmeric Lavender Coffee Creamer

This is a whole foods recipe that is sure to rock your socks and give your body a great boost first thing in the morning.

But don’t let the turmeric throw you off. A lot of people don’t care for the taste, but with the honey and turmeric, your body gets a great boost of anti-inflammatory benefits that it needs.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

48. S’mores Coffee Creamer

We have probably all enjoyed a warm s’more that was oozing with melted chocolate from the toasted marshmallow that came straight from being toasted over an open fire.

Well, if that brings back good memories for you and your taste buds, then you’ll want to consider giving this homemade coffee creamer a try.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

49. Peanut Butter Cup Coffee Creamer

Peanut butter cups are a personal weakness of mine. Whoever created the flavor combo of peanut butter and chocolate was an absolute genius in my opinion.

So now that I know you can have that same great flavor combo to accompany your coffee, I’m elated. It requires only a few basic ingredients and your coffee can be boosted to the next level of flavor town.

Make this Homemade Coffee Creamer

After viewing all of these homemade coffee creamers, hopefully, you’ll have found a few delicious ideas that will help you to enjoy your coffee a little more while saving you money.